How to Cook Chuck Eye Steak in Oven

This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy here.

Super EASY and crazy delicious butter and garlic infused ribeye steak that's seared in a cast iron pan and finished off in the oven in less than 20 minutes!

Make sure to serve this oven steak with super creamy mashed potatoes and air fryer asparagus for a complete meal.

overhead image of ribeye steak on a white plate with asparagus and brussels sprouts beside it.

Table Of Contents

What Makes This Ribeye Steak So Good
Here Are The Simple Ingredients You Will Need
How to cook ribeye steak in the oven
Ribeye steak temperature
How long to cook ribeye steak?
How To Get The Perfect Sear?
Ribeye steak price
Best Sides For Steak
Full Recipe Instructions

What Makes This Ribeye Steak So Good

You don't need any skills or a huge list of ingredients for this ribeye steak recipe. It's as simple as steak, oil, garlic, seasoning, and a tiny bit of butter (for flavor). The cooking time may vary depending on each oven and the size of the steak. My steaks were a little over 1 inch thick. 8 minutes in the oven got me a perfect medium-well steak. If you prefer your steak a little more rare, cook it for less than 8 minutes.

Here Are The Simple Ingredients You Will Need

Steak: Use bone-in ribeye for optimal flavor for the steak. You can use boneless if you prefer though.
Oil and Butter: The meat will need to be coated in olive oil or avocado oil before hitting the hot pan to create a nice sear. The butter will be added at the end of cooking to enhance flavor.
Spices: We love using Weber Chicago steak seasoning because the spice mix is amazing!
Garlic: The garlic is probably the best thing you can add to steak to give it the best addition of flavor.

overhead image os ingredients needed to make ribeye steak in the oven

How to cook ribeye steak in the oven

Rinse and pat the steak– As with any raw meat, I always rinse and pat my ribeye steaks dry with a paper towel.
Season the steak– Now drizzle a generous amount of olive oil over the rib eye steak and massage the pressed garlic over the entire steaks. Now season them with your favorite steak seasoning. I love using Weber's Chicago steak seasoning for this rib eye steak recipe.

two image collage of seasoning raw ribeye steak

Pan sear and finish in oven– Sear each side of the rib eye steak in the cast iron pan then finish them off in the oven with a slice of butter on top.

two image collage of bone-in ribeye steak being cooked in a cast iron pan with butter on top

Ribeye steak temperature

When cooking steaks, no matter if the steak recipe calls for grilling, baking, or panfrying, The USDA recommends that steaks at least reach an internal temperature of at least 145 degrees Fahrenheit to be considered safe to eat. of 145 degrees Fahrenheit for a medium cooked steak. The best way to determine the temperature of your meat is by inserting an instant-read thermometer into the thickest part of the meat.

Well done: 155-165 degrees Fahrenheit
Medium well:145 degrees Fahrenheit
For Medium: 135-145 degrees Fahrenheit
Medium rare: 130 to 135 degrees Fahrenheit (most people prefer it this way)
Rare:120-130 degrees Fahrenheit

close up image of sliced cooked steak with a fork piercing it

How long to cook ribeye steak?

Stovetop: Sear your 1 inch cast iron steak for 3 minutes on each side. Then baste with steak renderings for another 3-5 minutes.
Oven: Sear both sides of a 1-inch steak until well browned then finish the ribeye steak in the oven for about 5-7 minutes at 400 degrees Fahrenheit for a medium-well steak.
Grill: Set the grill to high heat for an inferred grill and medium-high for a direct flame grill. cook each side of the steak for about 5-6 minutes per side.
Steak bites: Since steak tips or steak bites are small, they cook very fast. Once they hit the hot cast iron pan, cook them for no more than 2-3 minutes.

How To Get The Perfect Sear?

The secret to getting a perfect brown crust on steak is high heat. When frying the pan in oil, you want to get the pan to at least 285 degrees Fahrenheit. That char is what will give the steak its amazing flavor. This insanely delicious flavoring method is also known as the Maillard reaction.

Ribeye steak price

The price for ribeye steak can vary from $9.99 to $14.99. I've seen ribeye go on sale for as low as $5.99 per pound before a holiday. That's a sweet deal so take advantage and save money by stocking up and freezing the steaks. We love to buy the ribeye when it's on sale and vacuum seal them in our food saver vacuum sealing system.

Best Sides For Steak

Every good steak needs a delicious side to go with it right? Here are our top recommendations for steak side dishes.

Scalloped potatoes
Super Creamy Mashed potatoes
Air Fryer Asparagus
Crispy Air fryer Brussels Sprouts
Couscous and arugula salad
Garlic Asparagus
Air fryer Broccoli

overhead image of ribeye steak with melted butter on top and cooked asparagus beside it

Full Recipe Instructions

overhead image of ribeye steak on a white plate with asparagus and brussels sprouts beside it.

▢ 2 bone-in ribeye steaks
▢ Olive oil
▢ 2 garlic cloves pressed
▢ Weber Chicago steak seasoning to taste
▢ 1 tbsp unsalted butter

Rinse and pat steaks

Rinse the steaks and pat away any extra blood from the meat using a paper towel. Drizzle olive oil over each side of the steaks.

Season the meat

Evenly spread the 2 pressed garlic cloves on both sides of the steaks and generously season with the Chicago steak seasoning.

Sear and finish in the oven

Heat 2 tbsp of olive oil in a cast-iron ribbed grill pan over high heat. Cook both sides of the steak in the cast iron pan until well browned. Use an instant-read thermometer to get the right temperature for your steaks. See notes for steak doneness.
Place 1/2 tbsp of butter on each steak and cook uncovered in the oven at 400 degrees Fahrenheit for 8 minutes.

Temperatures for Steak Doneness

Well done: 155-165 degrees Fahrenheit
Medium well: 145 degrees Fahrenheit
Medium: 135-145 degrees Fahrenheit
Medium rare: 130 to 135 degrees Fahrenheit (most people prefer it this way)
Rare: 120-130 degrees Fahrenheit

Snap a photo of it and tag me on Instagram @simplyhomecooked or use the hashtag #simplyhomecooked so I can see it and feature it!

This recipe was originally posted on Jan 28, 2016, we've tweaked it a bit since then.

Author
Recent Posts

Dina

Hi, I'm Dina, so glad you stopped by! I believe life is too short for bad coffee and boring meals. With my easy to follow step-by-step recipes, you'll be surprised at how quickly a wholesome and delicious meal can come together. I hope you find something you enjoy!